Reading thru all of this made me reflect upon a situation that occurred on another forum between me and a member I barely knew. Perhaps, this will help you, Mitch.
As I said, I barely knew the person, yet had seen him posting for months on the forum and we shared comments on a few posts. Like Scott, this guy "stood out" with his wit and personality.
However, one day, I noticed his posts changed. They were "darker" than usual, and I started watching his posts out of concern.
Somehow, we both ended up involved in a deep thread and his comments became more eerie. They started to change to past tense, and as someone that always CARED, he sudenly was like "whatever", life's over soon enough. Strange...
I kept engaging this person and started to share my concern in the thread about his "state". Others picked up on it and started to chime in, too.
After a while, I PM'd him and asked him to call me so we could talk on the phone. Several hours went by and nothing.
Instead he sent an email and his story was similar to Scott. Divorce after 25 years, lost his studio, bank took his car, he said he was tired and wanted to "go home".
So you can imagine how that struck me when I read Scott's post in Richard Hudson's song thread. Same choice of words. SAME.
In the end, this person called me, we spoke for hours, he hung up, went for a drive and then went to a close friend and told him what he almost did that night.
Seems one never truly knows. NONE of his family new, none of his friends, yet somehow he expressed himself on a forum, he said it was easier and said he would have never told his family the things he shared on the forum or on our phone conversation that night. He said "NOT KNOWING ME made it easier".
Weeks later he wrote to me and said the care and concern showed on the forum from people he did not know, somehow restored SOME level of faith in the world. He said is was either it was that, or since we "distracted him" for 10 hours, after the time passed it was no longer a "real option". Guess we'll never know.
Most chilling was his comment weeks later that NO ONE could have stopped him (if he had gone thru with it). Nothing could have been changed, or caught, or anything. Even our talk, our posts, the concern of the forum members. Nothing.
He said he simply was not able to, nor ready for "that option"...
I guess my point is, look how close a few of us were in "real-time" to this event with respect to his intentions. Even though some if us picked up on it, acted and stayed with it, it came down to HIS CHOICE, and his alone.
I wanted to share this story with you so you know you're not alone in matters like this. His choice of words, the forum connection, similar life traumas, all tie-in together - Scott and this person on the other forum.
Please hold onto the wonderful Scott stories, as this was your "real" brother. No doubt, you were very special to him.
That bond will ALWAYS be there. It may have been shorter than you would have liked, but it seems you shared an amazing journey together and I would take 20 years of Arby's stories and the like than 50 years of a so-so relationship with my brother.
In the end, no matter the cause, we're left with memories. Thankfully you are blessed to have many, many terrific memories of life with Scott.
God bless you and your family.
JS






